As Madden 22 included an image of Madden 22 coins two athletes on the cover so it's unlikely EA could repeat something like this once more. The cover has been done two times and If they continue to put an athlete on each cover it will detract from the importance it gives when it does happen. You also have to take into account that Brady Mahomes and Brady have both been featured twice on the cover and twice, it is unlikely that it will be either one of them.
As we take a look back at the previous athletes that have graced the cover before, it's hard to imagine like a year in which we'll be seeing any repeat athletes. There is only one repeat player I can imagine appearing included on the cover. all the others would be brand-new on the cover for Madden 23.
5. Matthew Stafford
A cover athlete is generally assumed to be an accurate representation from the previous season. If this is true then the current winning quarterback of Super Bowl LVI has to be added to this list. Matthew Stafford left the Detroit Lions to help bring the Super Bowl to Los Angeles and did exactly that. And, most impressively, it only took him 1 year to achieve this.
Quarterback is arguably the most buy madden coins important job in the game, especially in the modern-day day. Matthew Stafford proved that there was a quarterback problem at Los Angeles and his debut with the team resolved it and also a lot of other key pieces that the Rams brought in as well. I am imagining Stafford being one of the best options on Madden 23 cover. In addition, if EA decides to pick one who represented the last NFL season overall Matthew Stafford's name is bound to be flying around.